Well, that was poor wasn’t it?
At least I thought it was. I seriously struggle to find a single positive from that game, apart from the fact that we somehow got a point out of one of the worst performances of the season.
I’ll start with the attack, or rather the lack of it. Watkins must have been asking himself why he was involved at all, as for all the service he got, he may as well have stayed at home. Same as usual, I couldn’t really fault him.
His effort is second to none, but he had absolutely nothing to work off.
There was one stage where someone hoofed a thirty yard plus ball up to him and I quite frankly just laughed to myself. Enough said.
The midfield.
Good grief, where do I begin?
It was just horrendous. Where you normally get a half decent performance out of at least one midfielder in a rubbish performance, there wasn’t a solitary one last night.
It probably says it all when Jack Grealish has an off day.
Which is okay with me, as he’s been outstanding all season up to now.
But it’s not quite so acceptable for any of the others.
Traore and McGinn were plain poor, but Ross Barkley took things to another level.
I’m not going to harp on about it, but you’d have to be blind to not see that something is seriously not right with him.
Dean Smith can talk all he likes about how the players are not struggling in the slightest, but I’ll say it again, even stronger than I did previously. It’s bullshine.
Granted, Barkley was much better last time out, but he’s been poor since he came back from injury. Which coincidentally pretty much coincides with our run of poor performances.
Now, I’m not saying Barkley is necessarily pivotal to our game, but he is important and if he’s not right, it shows.
The reason being that he’s a good player. He’s skilled, strong and hard working generally. Ie, he has all the attributes.
And I fail to believe he’s suddenly just gone rubbish because of form.
He’s not trained at all, so why is he playing?
It’s not like he’s Paul McGrath, who could rely on his reading of the game to bring out a performance. With an attacking midfielder, you’re needed to make the game, not defend it.
Take Barkley and Grealish out of our game and you’re down to Traore. I’ve said I’m undecided on him and this game did nothing to convince me.
McGinn has just been out of form for a while to my mind, but he does at least work hard. He needs to find some form quickly, as patience is rapidly running out. As much as you can love a player, the love can only last for so long if it’s one-sided.
I give up, as I really can’t understand why we were so bad.
The saving grace is that the defence didn’t concede.
I was expecting some fans to say how good the defence was and looking around, it didn’t take long to find these sort of comments.
I’m sorry, but I massively disagree.
If you can call a defence that gives acres of space to the opposition just on the edge and inside of the box that they can pass it around like it’s a training day, a good defence, well, I obviously know nothing in all the time I’ve been watching the game.
And then there’s the panic, where we’re lashing balls to nowhere.
Don’t believe me?
Watch the game again.
Our defence is just as bad as the rest of the team has been over the last few weeks, but Mings and others have been good at last second shot stopping, I admit.
That is not a good defence. It’s a lucky one, that trust me, will be caught out against a good, incisive side.
Leicester and Leeds coming up soon, isn’t it?
Martinez was the only one who kept us in that game and I think if we’d have lost it three or four nil, none of us would be complaining much, because Brighton would probably have deserved it.
It was a repeat performance of the Arsenal game, where we were equally poor in my opinion.
The difference there though, was we got an early goal that proved to be the winner.
If we’d have done the same here, I wonder how many fans would be saying it was a great win?
I don’t profess to know what the problem is, but it’s obvious we’ve got one.
The big question is, does Dean Smith?
And can he do anything about it?
Just rubbish and I hope Smith can sort it out.
If I was a neutral, I’d be wondering how a team can suddenly become so poor if we’re not tired.
Think it’s a bit harsh to say they are not tired. Large part of squad had Covid recently…..there are long term effects with this disease.
Russel, you misunderstand me.
It was a bit of a jibe at Smith saying the players are not tired.
First game this season that I havent enjoyed watching. West Ham wasnt great, but were hopeless in this one. Thank God we signed a quality keeper!
Think a few changes will be incoming for the next game. No way can Barkley start again,,,and a couple of the others should be looking over their shoulder nervously too. With the improving quality of our squad, you cant play poorly and expect to keep your place.
Confirmed, Cash out with hamstring injury – usually these are 4 to 6 weeks.
Going to be a big miss – with Guilbert out on loan, Elmo to step up to the plate.
We will miss Cash. He has been very good, despite getting very little support from Traore.
Barkley irritates me. He tries back heels and flicks all the time and almost always loses possession. It’s almost as if he is trying to show he is as good as Grealish, which of course he isn’t.
I would start Sanson next match, but who to leave out for him is tricky. Trezeguet puts in a lot more effort than Traore, particularly defensively but tends to make the wrong decisions in attack, shooting almost every time the ball comes to him. I wouldn’t mind seeing Sanson on the right side of midfield, not as a winger but I feel he would get up and down, is positive and would support Elmo. I can’t see Elmo getting forward too much though.
i would probably bring Ramsey in too, maybe for Barkley but McGinn’s position must be under threat too.
We seem to lack cohesion, particularly if pressed by the opposition, which is surprising given the consistent team selection.
I’m glad we are pretty much safe from relegation, as we look like we could lose against pretty much anyone at the moment.
Our form has taken a bit of a dive recently but thanks to Martinez and last ditch defending, we have results wise done okay.
Its been a topic of conversation for us all for a while now. Stop Grealish and stop Villa! Until recently we have had a good balance going forward with Grealish on the left, Traore on the right and Watkins backed up by Barkley. Unfortunately apart from Watkins, our attacking players have been hit and miss. West Ham and Brighton especially have nullified Grealish so we look for inspiration from others.
I’m no football manager but I would like to see Nakamba start against Leicester with Luiz pushed further forward and young Ramsey or Sanson given a run out. I would also start Trezeguet instead of Traore. We know that Cash will be out so Elmo will get his place. Letting Guilbert go out is looking a silly move now if Elmo gets injured too.
One thing I don’t get is when Barkley was out injured, El Ghazi came in on the left with Grealish playing a more central role with Traore on the right. This worked really well but it seems that now Barkley is fit he plays regardless of his form. This forces Grealish out wide so he is easier to mark.
No player should feel comfortable that they are guaranteed a starting place. Competition for places is a healthy thing. El Ghazi was dropped for no excuse and that won’t help his morale.
{OLL, edited, to take out talk of a repeat}
It isn’t just 90 minutes v Brighton it is 178 minutes since we scored v Arsenal that Villa’s attack has been worked out by opponents with a plan to stop Grealish. Arsenal put in 2 right backs. Unluckily for them at the start their left back lost the ball and it was netted by a player on the penalty spot. Against which 2 right backs were as much use as a chocolate teapot.
I could give you a long analysis of the lot, but I will just do Konsa in this post, the others just bullet points.
Lop-sided, left-sided attack is too predictable.
No plan B to switch Grealish to right side.
Traoré cannot trap a ball played as a long pass.
Konsa cannot kick a long pass accurately.
Pulling McGinn and Luis back exposes these faults because they were patching them over when playing further forward.
Give the ball to Mings in the back line, as Konsa usually does, and Mings will launch the ball up the left side, over the midfield of our opponents, up to Watkins or Grealish. Only variety is a ground pass for Targett to run with – again on the left.
Have you ever seen Konsa do a mirror image on the right side? No you haven’t. Only reasonable conclusion is Konsa cannot hit the ball that far, or with any accuracy. How do we ever launch a right wing attack? Only when we rob opponents on that side or from passes out of the centre by McGinn and Douglas Luis, which they could make when they were further forward, but not since they have dropped deeper.
There have been times this season when the quality of our football has been outstanding. When held against the last decade, it has been a breath of fresh air.
When we see performances that are luke warm at best, not forgetting we have picked up 4/6 points, we are disappointed.
I think the combination of Covid and multiple matches in a short period of time have caught up with the players.
In terms of the next match I would like to see some changes. I think McGinn needs a rest and Nakamba having a game. With Cash out El Ghazi or Trezeguet to replace Troare. Elmohamady does not have the legs of Cash and will not be able to cope with Traire’s lack of defensive work. I’d also like to see Sanson play instead of Barclay.
But against this Smith likes consistency in selection, which I don’t have a problem with. Just 4 more points from 16 games and we won’t be relegated.
Think we are OK Sid – can’t see any of the bottom 3 topping 36 points 🙂
Newcastle might be in a spot of bother though if, say, Fulham were to go on a bit of a run.
I said at the time after the Newcastle match that I thought out display was awful. All the things that have multiplied up in the matches after, leaving us in a state of complete disarray.
Sure it IS to do with the Covid outbreak as Newcastle have been the same.
Be interesting to see how we play against Leicester.
OLL has a theory that we don’t like playing in cold weather – which has also been mentioned on other blogs. It’s going to be relatively mild – albeit windy – at the weekend!
I’m minded to think Covid and a consequent loss of form might be the more logical explanation 🙂
Our next 3 games are really tough. If we take 4 points then I will be happy with that. Smith has a lot of decisions to make this weekend. A case of stick or twist. McGinn, Barkley and Traore are probably most fans choices for being ‘rested’ I’m also concerned about Harvey Barnes up against Elmo. Guilbert would have been a better choice as he could have coped with his pace!
Badger
It always amazes me how the media like to start a transfer frenzy. The latest target is Konsa. The press are very slow to realise Villa are a new force. Our owners have stopped Villa being a selling club. If a player is to leave it will be because:
* Villa no longer require the player
* The player wants to leave.
* Stupid money is offered – but in this current pandemic there is little surplus money.
No longer will the vultures swoop and takeaway the likes of Barry, Milner and Young.
I am confident our new owners will be able to move us to the levels they aspire to. The major banana skin will be UEFA creating a protectionist champions league designed for the few by the few.
You’re right Sid.
It really annoys me, but some people love this sort of stuff, even though most of us just think it’s total rubbish.
In this case, Konsa has never even hinted at wanting to leave and why would he? He’s probably enjoying his football more than he ever has before. Same applies to all the others too.
And then, there’s not even been a hint that any club has been looking at any of our players.
Apart from what’s made up in the media, of course.
They’ll have Martinez moving next and he’s only been here five minutes.
Ok look, that story is doing the rounds too!
And after Wolves beating Leeds, Leeds will be stepping up their efforts to sign Heaton, particularly after their goalie dropped a bit of a rick tonight.
It’s laughable and I just take no notice of it.
And as you suggest, Lerner had had enough and was willing to get his money back.
Our current owners are nowhere near that stage.
They’re still building and piling the money in to prove it.
They’ll wave away any offers they’re not interested in.
Badger, is it just me who is put into moderation?
Holte, you and OLL.
And absolutely no-one else.
Still not got a clue why.
The only thing I can suggest is try a different mail address, but keep the same name. Even thowaway ones work for others.
And if that doesn’t work, change your name slightly too.
I’d guess just changing the mail will do it.
Either way, don’t forget, the first time you try something different, you’ll go into moderation till I’ve approved you.
If that doesn’t work, I have one more thing I can try, but it’s last resort.
So, are gonna kick Leicester’s ass tomorrow or what?
Lol, I’ll write my thoughts later 🙂
Test
Test with different email
Try again Holte, when you can. If you go into moderation this time, it has to be your IP address.
Badger, I use GiffGaff which is basically the O2 network. If I’m using my phones data instead of WiFi I can’t send emails via my BT account because the IPs are all blacklisted.
I know an excellent WordPress guys if you want a hand…
Absolutely, I’d like a hand, if he can help out at all 🙂
I’m hearing that Grealish may be out tomorrow. No definate on this but it seems a couple of Villa players have taken him out of their fantasy football team for tomorrow.
May be complete bo**ocks of course!
Test again using wi-fi.
Same IP address Holte. It’s looking like that’s what it is.