Amavi to Sevilla is OFF: Shenanigans or a serious problem?

According to Spanish sources, the Amavi move has been knocked back after the player failed a medical which showed that the player has a significant risk of the cruciate knee injury that he suffered while playing for France, re-occurring.
Now it’s well known that Sevilla will try any trick in the book to get a player’s price down (and why not? it’s good business sense, something we’ve sorely lacked recently) and if so, you’d hope we’ll give them short shrift and not even entertain the idea of them getting him on a loan or even at cut price.
And indeed “significant risk” is a matter of judgement that might well mean they’re trying it on.
For any expert in any area, you can always find someone who thinks the opposite, after all.

But my worry is what if this is all plausible and Amavi does have that significant risk?
Even though there is supposed to be a fair amount of interest in the player, surely this will see him being valued at a much lower worth?

All in all, this is a fairly big bombshell, as surely we were banking on getting a good few quid for Amavi, which in turn, must have made his sale pivotal to our spending plans?
I don’t want to be the doom-monger that some of you paint me out to be, but the fact is, this could quite easily put paid to any more spending in this window, because if as we suspect, we wanted another two or three players in, the sums are beginning to not add up

You would have to hope that Sevilla are indeed just playing their usual games.
But even then, just the talk of this will surely mean any other interest will wane, at best.
If we were in a better financial position, I’d have liked to see Dr Xia tell Sevilla that we’ll never do business with them again.
The trouble is, I suspect our hand might already have been forced and we’ll have to let him go on the cheap.

It’ll be interesting to see what happens.

178 Comments

Page 10 of 10 1 8 9 10
  1. nath July 15, 2017 at 9:02 am . Reply

    our activities are slow in transfers. i don’t have any inside knowledge on this situation. but i believe its the fair play regulations. as i believe we are 1million under this rule. so unable to spend on transfers. until they sell. but nobody (clubs) wants to buy our crap ๐Ÿ™ they know we are desperate and they are playing the waiting game. knowing villa will have to reduce or miss out on their incoming targets.

    this is very frustrating. but its also proof we have been a soft touch in recent past,to other clubs and players offering them much more wages than they deserve and longer contracts as well.

  2. Langfordvilla July 15, 2017 at 9:05 am . Reply

    Morning all! Only 21 days to go before we tear this league to shreds!

    More than happy with Johnstone. I’m convinced the he’ll do the business. What a defence we have, the best in this division my a country mile.

    My man…as I said last week, said that Elmohamady was in Brum for a medical last Sunday. I actually saw the Hull City tweet saying ‘Elmo_27, wishing the players good luck for next season’. Havent heard from him since! I am guessing that the Amavi saga pushed things back a little. Hull were also waiting to replace Elmohamady, they have now done this by loaning a Chelsea youngster! My guess is that the Mail has probably got this right! Perhaps the Cissokho move is now funding it?

    UTV

    1. nath July 15, 2017 at 9:13 am . Reply

      what do you know about that clarke center defender, who played at telford ??? he seems very accomplished defending and bringing the ball out of defense

  3. Langfordvilla July 15, 2017 at 9:18 am . Reply

    Nath…Clark came on for Baker and formed an an excellent CB pairing with Samba. He seemed very comfortable on the ball for such a young lad. Looks like he could have a promising future!

    UTV

    1. nath July 15, 2017 at 9:21 am . Reply

      is he local lad ?? i assume hes from our youth team, i watched that game on friday. he impressed me very much.

      1. Langfordvilla July 15, 2017 at 9:38 am . Reply

        Mitchell Clark is Welsh.

        UTV

      2. Hitchens 60 July 15, 2017 at 9:41 am . Reply

        Mitchell Clark – 18 years old and Welsh international at U19’s. Member if Academy squad but also played for U23’s last season and has been at Villa for some time – all according to OS

        His pick up and run from defence to earn the penalty was very impressive.

        1. nath July 15, 2017 at 9:56 am . Reply

          thanks guys ๐Ÿ™‚

  4. nath July 15, 2017 at 9:28 am . Reply

    england reached 4 finals in youth competitions this summer. suliman also defender is representing england this weekend hopefully. we should build villa with a MADE IN GB stamped on it. or better made in west midlands ๐Ÿ™‚ i believe its what us fans want. we don’t mind a few johnny foreigner, but we want our own out their fighting for our causes

    1. Andrew July 15, 2017 at 9:53 am . Reply

      And that’s exactly what’s wrong with Villa and why we are where we are now.

      1. Andrew July 15, 2017 at 9:56 am . Reply

        And no, I’m not saying having home grown talent isn’t a bad thing. It’s great, but they’re just nowhere near as talented as their foreign counterparts for the same price.

      2. nath July 15, 2017 at 10:03 am . Reply

        finally we agree on something

        i don’t mind a few none British, but i want to see young local lads progress through the villa set up. go on to represent england. ๐Ÿ™‚

        i also am angry about offering long lucrative contracts to players like richards. who gave him a contract worth the amounts hes on and the length, he was a good prospect at manchester city years ago. done very little since. i expect not many clubs were in direct competition with us to sign him. so the sensible thing was to offer a 12month deal with clauses of better improved deal if he impressed.

  5. nath July 15, 2017 at 10:23 am . Reply

    we are aston villa and used to produce our own players. we could and should start producing again. to stop wasting money on players wages like richards. he has done little in 24 months and i doubt will contribute anything for the rest of his contract. i could name more or foreign ones

    i think watching the two friendlies we have talented youth. i think this is where we should be were we focussed on. players like davis and green are almost 1st team. grealish has been around that spot for too long. he must start to realize this before he misses the boat. also Oโ€™Hare i havent seen before and he preformed really well on the right wing.

    we seem to have quite a lot of center backs strength coming through, better already than richards. if they are training with terry and samba that will bring them on lots.

    iam liking the squad steve bruce is building. we need to get rid of alot of players. i can see more than green shoots now. the future will be claret and blue

  6. nath July 15, 2017 at 10:41 am . Reply

    another reason to get the production line of home grown superstars in full flow. have you seen the size of transfers happening in premiership. 55 million for a fullback that was at villa on loan. he is never worth 55million. currently somebody is going to get really hurt playing this game. i can see in the next 5 years to ten some big clubs going to the pan chasing a impossible dream

    1. Hitchens 60 July 15, 2017 at 11:54 am . Reply

      Has all the hallmarks of an investment type ‘bubble’ – continued and unchecked growth in income at the current rate must be unsustainable as are the ridiculously inflated transfer fees. Wages may be a different dynamic as we do live in a world where ‘entertainers’ are able to command huge incomes.

      Would be interesting to hear OLL’s views

  7. nath July 15, 2017 at 1:11 pm . Reply

    got my beer chilling all ready for this game today. ๐Ÿ™‚

    back to my johnny foreigner bashing. before the premiership their was hardly any foreigners in the english leagues. teams had one or two but these were not on ridiculous amounts of money. if my memory serves me well, the league had rules,you could only field was it 3 foreigners. this was around the time we had the irish players staughton houghton mcgrath even some irish players were halted by this rule. but football was played to better standards than today.

    we should aim for 60 70% english players, not go down the route of thinking foreign players are better. we invented the game for goodness sake. i could name loads of foreign that were failures. does mean not having a British passport means they are sure for success. english might cost in transfers but this isn’t my suggestion i said PRODUCE them. once we are producing decent standards we could sell for 100% profitts, instead of paying 55 million for a full back that only real quality is speed

  8. Langfordvilla July 15, 2017 at 2:14 pm . Reply

    Terry appointed captain….no surprise there IMO

    UTV

  9. GIDDYVILLAN July 15, 2017 at 2:18 pm . Reply

    JT is captain for the 2017/18 campaign, could I see this coming possibly yes

Right or Wrong? What do YOU think?

%d bloggers like this: